Re^2: Mutator chaining considered harmful

in reply to Re: Mutator chaining considered harmful
in thread Mutator chaining considered harmful

Chained method calls make backwards compatibility hard to do, if you make an attribute into its own object at any time. You can't use Want.pm, because either way you want an object. You mean, it makes it difficult to change a method such that has a different return value? Well, that always is non-backwards compatible. Whether the user chains, or stores the result in a variable and does something with the variable, it's going to be non-backwards compatible.

Chained method calls force a person reading to check whether a mutator has returned the same object or a more specific object. And that's different from storing the result of a method (whether said method is a mutator or something else) in a variable, and call a method in said variable?

Comment on Re^2: Mutator chaining considered harmful

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^3: Mutator chaining considered harmful by Anonymous Monk on Dec 31, 2004 at 06:29 UTC
Re: And that's different from storing the result of a method (whether said method is a mutator or something else) in a variable, and call a method in said variable? Yes, it is. Consider: `$people->bob->eye('green')->color;`. As a reader, I assume that the call is returning an 'eye' object, not bob, again. But if eye's a mutator, then you might find out Bob's a brown man. Re: You mean, it makes it difficult to change a method such that has a different return value? Well, that always is non-backwards compatible. Whether the user chains, or stores the result in a variable and does something with the variable, it's going to be non-backwards compatible. In most cases you can make it backwards compatible through Want.pm. But perhaps, this is an issue of my style...?	[reply] [d/l]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.

Re^3: Mutator chaining considered harmful
by Anonymous Monk on Dec 31, 2004 at 06:29 UTC

And that's different from storing the result of a method (whether said method is a mutator or something else) in a variable, and call a method in said variable?

$people->bob->eye('green')->color;

You mean, it makes it difficult to change a method such that has a different return value? Well, that always is non-backwards compatible. Whether the user chains, or stores the result in a variable and does something with the variable, it's going to be non-backwards compatible.

[reply]
[d/l]

In Section Meditations