I think you are both having an odd argument.

I'm not entirely sure whether either of you are currently posting further replies to one another at the time of writing this, but I am sure that you haven't replied to my post.

Hang on though, by the time someone else reads this there might be a reply. Dang.

OK. I've got it. I'm writing this post. That means you can't reply to it yet. But there may be replies to come.

Maybe you're having an ZXY argument?

FAKE EDIT - this post has not been edited.

AHA! I have it. I am not going to post this, then you can't reply it!

PS: I agree with this reply.