Beefy Boxes and Bandwidth Generously Provided by pair Networks
"be consistent"

Re: Extraterrestrials haven't visited the Earth yet because:

by perldigious (Priest)
on Sep 01, 2016 at 14:04 UTC ( [id://1170971]=note: print w/replies, xml ) Need Help??

in reply to Extraterrestrials haven't visited the Earth yet because:

Oh, I like this poll. It's fun to talk about this stuff.

I had to say "Other reason" because I think it's probably a combination of factors. I doubt a or b are true due simply to universal scale. I figure there is probably extraterrestrial life and furthermore there is probably intelligent life that would be suitably capable of interstellar travel. It would seem statistically unlikely that humans are the "only" or even "the first".

The next question would be do they know fundamental things we don't about the universe and have they been able to exploit that knowledge to develop technology that allows them to travel (safely) between star systems faster than light? If not that would be the "Interstellar travel is too difficult" option, with the difficulty increased if there are no relatively nearby star systems with this hypothetical intelligent life. That seems plausible based on the current human understanding of the universe, but humans have made drastic advances before that largely void the current state of that understanding of "what we think we know now". Even if faster than light travel between systems is possible, the scale of the universe combined with a low (if it is really low) likelihood of life (let alone intelligent life) developing could still make it extremely unlikely for any two intelligent species to find each other. There's also the 4th dimension to consider with time. Perhaps there was or will be life here or there, but not right now while we are looking for them or when they were/will be looking for us, that could be a big killer to different intelligent species ever finding each other as well.

I think "We're too uncool / not worth the trouble" is plausible because any species advanced enough to come to us may not be sufficiently interested by us, but that already assumes there is another intelligent species aware of us and that just seems unlikely to me (maybe I'm too close minded on that). I look at "What do you mean they haven't visited?" in the same way, not entirely implausible (heck sufficiently advanced technology could have them observing us from their own home), but it just seems really unlikely to me.

I love it when things get difficult; after all, difficult pays the mortgage. - Dr. Keith Whites
I hate it when things get difficult, so I'll just sell my house and rent cheap instead. - perldigious
  • Comment on Re: Extraterrestrials haven't visited the Earth yet because:

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: Extraterrestrials haven't visited the Earth yet because:
by jonadab (Parson) on Sep 10, 2016 at 21:39 UTC
    there is probably intelligent life that would be suitably capable of interstellar travel. It would seem statistically unlikely that humans are the "only" or even "the first"

    We're neither, not by a very long shot, and the fact that you can even say this implies that you have not grasped the scale or scope that would be involved. We are, in fact, not significantly closer to being capable of interstellar travel now than we were three millennia ago.

    Yes, we can now, in theory, build devices capable of unmanned interstellar travel; but they're preposterously expensive, wouldn't accomplish much, and would take dozens of human lifespans to reach even the nearest alien star systems and would not be able to stop when they do get there, other than by crashing into something. They might be able to radio back a little information, but the distance makes both lag and bandwidth a real problem, and absolutely positively everything would have to be entirely pre-programmed and so would be very, very primitive in terms of its capabilities compared to what NASA and similar agencies do with in-system probes, all of which receive and carry out instructions interactively as they go, generated by earth-based scientists who are looking at the data the probe just sent and deciding what to do based on it, something that would be fundamentally impossible with a multi-year communications lag (particularly given that the device would, by virtue of the nature of the mission, be moving at rather high speed, by human standards).

    In fact, it is not at all clear that we will ever achieve (manned or practical) interstellar travel. We're real proud of the fact that we've achieved "space flight", by which we mean landing on the moon a couple of times and sending unmanned probes around our solar system, but interstellar flight is an entirely different matter altogether. It's like the difference between school boys putting a six-foot-long plank across a creek to get across without needing to take their socks and shoes off (or get them wet), versus building a nuclear submarine to explore the ocean under the north pole. Actually, I think it's quite a bit more of a difference than that. Even sending a data-collection probe to one very (by interstellar standards) near star system would be a logistical feat that would make all the in-system stuff we've done to-date seem like nothing. And, in turn, sending a single data-collection probe to one very nearby star system would be nothing at all compared to actually exploring the galaxy, much less the universe.

    Personally, I am convinced that A) there almost certainly is not alien extra-terrestrial life in other star systems, but B) even if there were, the odd are very very low that any of it would develop practical interstellar travel and furthermore C) even if they did, we would almost certainly never find out about it, because the odds they would travel here, specifically, out of all the places they could go, are much, much lower than the odds that a multi-billionaire I've never heard of has named me in his will and will die tomorrow.

Log In?

What's my password?
Create A New User
Domain Nodelet?
Node Status?
node history
Node Type: note [id://1170971]
and the web crawler heard nothing...

How do I use this?Last hourOther CB clients
Other Users?
Others surveying the Monastery: (1)
As of 2024-04-25 02:38 GMT
Find Nodes?
    Voting Booth?

    No recent polls found