I strongly think not, and that is a gripe of mine.

Don't get me wrong. I use comments, and on the whole I have quite a few of them. But to me comments are something which has to be done right or else it is worse than useless, and I would prefer to see completely uncommented code to overly verbosely commented code.

For a thread that outlines my personal commenting style and the reasons for it at some length, I would suggest reading Re (tilly) 2 (disagree): Another commenting question,. (Note that behind the scenes we traded a series of /msgs that were more friendly than the discussion there.) After reading that, if you think that I really need more comments than I use, or that my points about how comments can be a problem are off-target, please give me feedback.