Test::More bug?

jens has asked for the wisdom of the Perl Monks concerning the following question:

I have been working my way through the examples in Test::Tutorial and the very first example does not work as expected. At first I thought I was doing something wrong. (hey, maybe I am!) But as far as I can tell, there's no way these inputs should give these outputs. Check out the following code:

#!/usr/bin/perl -w
use strict;

use Test::More tests => 8;
use Date::ICal;

    my $ical = Date::ICal->new( year => 1964,
                                month => 10,
                                day => 6,
                                hour => 6,
                                min => 12,
                                sec => 47,
                                tz => '0530'
                            );

    ok( defined $ical,              'new() returned something' );
    ok( $ical->isa('Date::ICal'),   "  and it's the right class" );
    is( $ical->sec   , 47,          '  sec()'   );
    is( $ical->min   , 12,          '  min()'   );
    is( $ical->hour  , 16,          '  hour()'  );
    is( $ical->day   , 16,          '  day()'   );
    is( $ical->month , 10,          '  month()' );
    is( $ical->year  , 1964,        '  year()'  );
[download]

Running this code with a debugging 'perl testmore.pl' gives the following output:

[jens@dhcp32 jens]$ perl testmore.pl
1..8
ok 1 - new() returned something
ok 2 -   and it's the right class
ok 3 -   sec()
ok 4 -   min()
not ok 5 -   hour()
#     Failed test (testmore.pl at line 20)
#          got: '20'
#     expected: '16'
not ok 6 -   day()
#     Failed test (testmore.pl at line 21)
#          got: '5'
#     expected: '16'
ok 7 -   month()
ok 8 -   year()
# Looks like you failed 2 tests of 8.
[download]

How is Test::More coming up with these values? (or is it correctly indicating a bug in Date::Ical?)

Note: if you examine this example in Test::Tutorial, you'll notice I've changed values of hour and day from 16 for both to 6. My first original test--cut and pasted out of Test::Tutorial--gave me an error on hour:


not ok 5 -   hour()
#     Failed test (testmore.pl at line 20)
#          got: '6'
#     expected: '16'
[download]

Can anyone else verify this bug? Obviously this is a bug in the docco Test::Tutorial. But is it a bug in Test::More or in Date::Ical? (or have I done something weird?)

Comment on Test::More bug? Select or Download Code

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: Test::More bug? by chromatic (Archbishop) on Aug 30, 2002 at 18:14 UTC
It was actually a bug in Date::Ical that the writing of Test::Tutorial exposed. There's an explanation of this in the Test::Tutorial slides, starting around slide 37.	[reply]
Re: Test::More bug? by danichka (Hermit) on Aug 30, 2002 at 05:45 UTC
Your tests and your data to test don't match up. With a few changes this runs fine for me. #!/usr/bin/perl -w use strict; use Test::More tests => 8; use Date::ICal; my $ical = Date::ICal->new( year => 1964, month => 10, day => 6, hour => 6, min => 12, sec => 47, tz => '0530' ); ok( defined $ical, 'new() returned something' ); ok( $ical->isa('Date::ICal'), " and it's the right class" ); is( $ical->sec , 47, ' sec()' ); is( $ical->min , 12, ' min()' ); is( $ical->hour , 12, ' hour()' ); #changed to 12 is( $ical->day , 6, ' day()' ); #changed to 6 is( $ical->month , 10, ' month()' ); is( $ical->year , 1964, ' year()' ); [download] Of Course your tz may be different from mine (and that of the author of the module) which would seem to explain the first error you got. use Your::Head;	[reply] [d/l]
Re: Re: Test::More bug? by jens (Pilgrim) on Aug 30, 2002 at 06:05 UTC
Your tests and your data to test don't match up. With a few changes this runs fine for me. Yes, that was the idea! I'm expecting it to say:"test failed: got 6" but instead it says "20" and "5"! Also, when all the values match up as they should, I still get an error. When I try cutting and pasting the precise example from 'perldoc Test::Tutorial', my actual and tested values for hour are '16' but it says it actually "got 6".!! use Your::Eyes;	[reply]
Re: Re: Re: Test::More bug? by danichka (Hermit) on Aug 30, 2002 at 15:37 UTC
I'm expecting it to say:"test failed: got 6" but instead it says "20" and "5"! 20 is the line number and 5 is the test number that failed. When I try cutting and pasting the precise example from 'perldoc Test::Tutorial', my actual and tested values for hour are '16' but it says it actually "got 6" Like I said last time I think this is because your timezone is different from the author's. If I am wrong hopefully someone will clear that up. use Your::Eyes; I did, but they were tired and kept trying to close on me. Seriously though my "use Your::Head;" is merely my sig and wasn't an insult nor was it directed at you. I also think that it is a little silly to downvote some of my very old nodes over this. use Your::Head;	[reply]
Re: Test::More bug? by projekt21 (Friar) on Aug 30, 2002 at 17:08 UTC
Looking at Date::ICal version 1.70, it says: new() handles timezones. It defaults times to UTC (Green wich Mean Time, also called Zulu). If you want to set up a time that's in the US "Pacific" timezone, which is GMT-8, use something like: `my $ical = Date::ICal->new( ical => '19971024T120000', offset => "-0800");` [download] That 'tz' has no effect for me. Your example gives: `1..8 ok 1 - new() returned something ok 2 - and it's the right class ok 3 - sec() not ok 4 - min() # Failed test (test056.pl at line 19) # got: '42' # expected: '12' not ok 5 - hour() # Failed test (test056.pl at line 20) # got: '0' # expected: '16' not ok 6 - day() # Failed test (test056.pl at line 21) # got: '6' # expected: '16' ok 7 - month() ok 8 - year() # Looks like you failed 3 tests of 8.` [download] after changing the tz-line to `offset => '+0530'` [download] This looks correct. P.S. My sig is no insult, too :-) alex pleiner <alex@zeitform.de> zeitform Internet Dienste	[reply] [d/l] [select]


Just another Perl shrine
	PerlMonks