Re: stuck with a \N{CHAR NAME} problem

{
   use charnames ":alias" => { FOO => 0x2660 };
   my $pat1 = '\N{FOO}';
   $re1 = qr/$pat1/;
}

{
   use charnames ":alias" => { FOO => 0x2661 };
   my $pat2 = '\N{FOO}';
   $re2 = qr/$pat2/;
}

{
   use charnames ":alias" => { FOO => 0x2662 };
   /$re1$re2/
}
[download]

What should the pattern match? Probably /\N{U+2660}\N{U+2661}/, but the information is not available to qr// at run-time, much less to the m// operator that's not in scope of the relevant directives.

Those problems were resolved by converting \N{NAME} to \N{U+NUM} at compile-time, and throwing an error when presented with \N{NAME} at run-time.

"\N{NAME}" works. qr/\N{NAME}/ works. Others, not so much.

Comment on Re: stuck with a \N{CHAR NAME} problem Select or Download Code

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: stuck with a \N{CHAR NAME} problem by tchrist (Pilgrim) on May 26, 2011 at 17:52 UTC
Alias games aside, I have yet to read any argument for why `\N{NAME}` should not simply use the currently active charmap, and/or autoload the `:full` one. This would handle all but the rarest sitatuations, and it would make Perl stop violating the principle of least surprise. In other words, instead of generating an exception like `Constant(\N{NAME}) unknown: (possibly a missing "use charnames ...")` [download] It should in that situation implicitly do a `use charnames ":full";` [download] and get on with it. In other words, if you need a charmap and don't have one, just load what everybody is expecting.	[reply] [d/l] [select]
Re^3: stuck with a \N{CHAR NAME} problem by ikegami (Patriarch) on May 26, 2011 at 18:28 UTC
Auto-loading :full would be most desireable, but it wouldn't help here. It seems to me the OP's issue could be resolved by attaching charnames data to statements (just like strict flags). Then, qr// could translate \N{NAME} to \N{U+NUM} at run-time just like it does at compile-time. That would even handle aliases. Is that hard to do?	[reply]


There's more than one way to do things
	PerlMonks