my $AoH; for my $n_rec (1, 10, 100, 1000) { say ""; say "=== num of records is: ", $n_rec; $AoH = create_data (1, $n_rec); is_deeply ([ sort $_->() ], [ sort &slice_join ]) for \&list_join, \&grep_map, \&map_map; cmpthese ( -1, { map_map => \&map_map, grep_map => \&grep_map, list_join => \&list_join, slice_join => \&slice_join, }); } done_testing; sub list_join { my %H; %H = (%H, %$_) for @$AoH; return keys %H; } # list_join sub slice_join { my %H; @H{keys %$_} = () for @$AoH; return keys %H; } # slice_join sub grep_map { my %seen; return grep { !$seen{$_}++ } map { keys %$_ } @$AoH; } # grep_map sub map_map { my %H = map { $_ => 1 } map { keys %$_ } @$AoH; return keys %H; } # map_map sub create_data { my ($density, $records) = @_; my @AoH; push @AoH, {map { rand 100 <= $density ? ("$_" => $_) : () } "A" .. "ZZ"} for 1 .. $records; return \@AoH; } #### === num of records is: 1 ok 1 ok 2 ok 3 Rate map_map list_join grep_map slice_join map_map 508970/s -- -18% -19% -45% list_join 619376/s 22% -- -1% -33% grep_map 625570/s 23% 1% -- -33% slice_join 928647/s 82% 50% 48% -- === num of records is: 10 ok 4 ok 5 ok 6 Rate list_join map_map grep_map slice_join list_join 12444/s -- -80% -83% -88% map_map 61440/s 394% -- -17% -42% grep_map 73770/s 493% 20% -- -30% slice_join 105217/s 746% 71% 43% -- === num of records is: 100 ok 7 ok 8 ok 9 Rate list_join map_map grep_map slice_join list_join 174/s -- -97% -98% -98% map_map 5966/s 3332% -- -25% -43% grep_map 7952/s 4474% 33% -- -24% slice_join 10479/s 5928% 76% 32% -- === num of records is: 1000 ok 10 ok 11 ok 12 Rate list_join map_map grep_map slice_join list_join 6.67/s -- -99% -99% -99% map_map 545/s 8070% -- -47% -56% grep_map 1027/s 15299% 88% -- -17% slice_join 1244/s 18553% 128% 21% --