c:\@Work\Perl\monks>perl -wMstrict -le "use 5.010; ;; my @records = ( ',P,Q,R,S', 'A,,D,E,F', 'L,T,,G,Q', 'C,D,E,,L', 'V,W,X,Y,', ' , , , ,', ',,,,', ',', ' , ', '', ' ', ); ;; for my $rec (@records) { print qq{'$rec'}; $rec =~ s{ (?: \A | ,) \K \s* (?= ,) | (?<= ,) \s* (?= , | \z) | \A \s* \z }{NULL}xmsg; print qq{'$rec' \n}; } " ',P,Q,R,S' 'NULL,P,Q,R,S' 'A,,D,E,F' 'A,NULL,D,E,F' 'L,T,,G,Q' 'L,T,NULL,G,Q' 'C,D,E,,L' 'C,D,E,NULL,L' 'V,W,X,Y,' 'V,W,X,Y,NULL' ' , , , ,' 'NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL' ',,,,' 'NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL' ',' 'NULL,NULL' ' , ' 'NULL,NULL' '' 'NULL' ' ' 'NULL'