foreach my $i (1..$cards) { my %seen; . . . for my $x (1..4) { for my $y (1..4) { my $word; while (1) { my $index = rand(@words); $word = $words[$index]; if (!$seen{$word}) { $seen{$word}++; last; } } . . . #### use Algorithm::Numerical::Shuffle qw /shuffle/; . . . foreach my $i (1..$cards) { . . . @words = shuffle @words; for my $x (1..4) { for my $y (1..4) { my $word = shift @words; . . .