##
print for keys %seen;
# will print paul, jane, betty (though not necessarily in this order, see note below)
####
$seen{paul} = 1; # this does absolutely nothing! but...
++$seen{paul}; # paul's *value* is 2 now
print for keys %seen; # yet this still prints the same list
####
@list = grep !$temp{$_}++, @list; # same thing, shorter.