my $first=0; while () { chomp ($_); my $element = $_; if ($first == 0) { $first = 1; # don't print a comma before the first element } else { print ","; # print a comma } print $element; } print "\n"; __DATA__ foo bar blivitz this is a line 1 2 a b cde #### foo ,bar ,blivitz ,this is a line ,1 ,2 ,a ,b ,cde