in reply to Re: Capturing regex from map
in thread Capturing regex from map

...take a look at the grep function...

Help me understand how grep will pass only the captures from a regex, as map does in this case.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^3: Capturing regex from map
by Laurent_R (Canon) on Sep 13, 2013 at 18:09 UTC

    You are right, grep will not do captures in such a situation. I might not have been clear, but I only mentionned is as an additional useful tool in similar synctactic context, for filtering purpose.

    Having said that you can do something akin to captures in a grep, although it is not very clean. Consider this:

    DB<1> @a = qw (foobar barfoo foobaz, bar, foobor); DB<2> @c = grep {s/fo(ob.).+/$1/} @a; DB<3> x @c 0 'oba' 1 'oba' 2 'obo'

    Not clean, I would not really recommend it, but not impossible.

      Not clean ...

      ... in part, perhaps, because the  @a input array is affected (via aliasing) and winds up 'oba-oba-obo-ed':

      >perl -wMstrict -le "my @a = qw(foobar barfoo foobaz bar foobor); my @c = grep {s/fo(ob.).+/$1/} @a; ;; printf qq{'$_' } for @c; print qq{\n}; printf qq{'$_' } for @a; " 'oba' 'oba' 'obo' 'oba' 'barfoo' 'oba' 'bar' 'obo'

        Yes, you are absolutely right, this is definitely one of the main reasons why it is not clean in my mind (and I upvoted your comment). But you can also make a temporary copy if you want to keep the original array intact, no big deal if the data is nor too large. But again, I am not suggesting this as a good solution. It might just be a possible useful alternative in some edge cases or very specific context, although I fail to see any.