Re^2: perldoc GIT bash

After checking my install, it appears that only some of the perl scripts in Strawberry's installation are configured with full paths for the shebang line, which causes its own set of issues. Those are the items that should have a bug attached to them, either in the package, or on Strawberry itself. (IMO, of course)

Hmm, seeing how win32 perl doesn't rely on shebang, has cmd.exe as its shell ... where as msysgit (git-bash) comes with its own perl ... doesn't look like strawberryperl needs any bug reports regarding this

Comment on Re^2: perldoc GIT bash

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^3: perldoc GIT bash by MidLifeXis (Monsignor) on Mar 28, 2014 at 19:18 UTC
Unless you are only using the shell from msys, and using the Strawberry perl installation. This is as the OP stated. I actually agree that Strawberry is not the proper place for the bug report. I would argue that it is a bug in the original packages that are included in the Strawberry distribution. Even if not on Strawberry with an msys shell, the same thing can happen with multiple perl installations under unix. If the shebang is hardcoded in the distribution and the installation script does not rewrite the shebang line to the full path of the perl installation it is installed into, the script will use the wrong perl when executing itself. Under unix, it appears that the script gets rewritten (at least what I could test). Under Strawberry, it does not look like it does. An interesting scenario probably best to be avoided. --MidLifeXis	[reply]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.

Re^3: perldoc GIT bash
by MidLifeXis (Monsignor) on Mar 28, 2014 at 19:18 UTC

Unless you are only using the shell from msys, and using the Strawberry perl installation. This is as the OP stated.

I actually agree that Strawberry is not the proper place for the bug report. I would argue that it is a bug in the original packages that are included in the Strawberry distribution. Even if not on Strawberry with an msys shell, the same thing can happen with multiple perl installations under unix. If the shebang is hardcoded in the distribution and the installation script does not rewrite the shebang line to the full path of the perl installation it is installed into, the script will use the wrong perl when executing itself. Under unix, it appears that the script gets rewritten (at least what I could test). Under Strawberry, it does not look like it does.

An interesting scenario probably best to be avoided.

--MidLifeXis

[reply]