Following the discussion in Why eval $version? I'd like to propose the following approach.

Usage

use Version::Easy;

$VERSION = 'v1.2.3';     # v-str

# or...
$VERSION = '1.002003';   # float 
$VERSION = 'v1.2.3_4';   # v-str + alpha
$VERSION = '1.002003_4'; # float + alpha
[download]

please note that:

• Version::Easy adds magic to $VERSION
• it's also declaring $VERSION in the caller's package, so no our needed
• all formats like floats or v-strings with optional "_alpha" allowed
• no boilerplate eval or tr/// needed
• version is used internally, which is the same mechanism applied by use
• syntax check at runtime
• toolchain modules with static parser find "$VERSION" as usual

Implementation:

• $VERSION is a tied scalar,
• in STORE the version number is checked for correct syntax
• in FETCH a version object is returned
• the version object is overloading all necessary operators
• for older versions of Perl the implementation could adapt dynamically to sane defaults
• if the performance impact is too heavy for normal runs, it's possible to limit the costly parts only to run inside the test suite.

Doesn't this solve most (or all) problems???

Please comment! Where does this fail? :)

use strict;
use warnings;

# --------------------------------------------------

package Version::Easy;
use Data::Dump qw/pp dd/;
use version;

sub import {
    my $pkg = (caller)[0];

    my $version;
    tie $version, 'Version::Easy::Tie';

    no strict 'refs';
    *{${pkg}."::VERSION"} = \$version;
}

# --------------------------------------------------
package Version::Easy::Tie;

require Tie::Scalar;
our @ISA = qw(Tie::StdScalar);
use version qw/is_lax/;

sub STORE {
    my ($self,$value)= @_;
    warn "IN:\t\t",$value;
    if ( is_lax($value) ) {
        $$self = version->parse($value);

    } else {
        warn "corrupt VERSION format $value";
    }
}

# BUG? perldoc Tie::Scalar says no TIESCALAR needed
sub TIESCALAR {
    my $class = shift;
    my $version;
    return bless \$version, $class;
}


1;

# --------------------------------------------------

# ---  fake already required for 'use' demo

BEGIN {
    $INC{'Version/Easy.pm'} = 1;
}

# --------------------------------------------------
#
#      DEMO
#
#

package TST;

use Version::Easy;

# --------- test v-str
$VERSION = 'v1.2.3';

warn "Str:\t"   ,$VERSION;
warn "Float:\t" ,$VERSION->numify;
warn "V-str:\t" ,$VERSION->normal;

my $v1 = $VERSION;

# --------- test float
$VERSION = '1.002003';

warn "Str:\t"   ,$VERSION;
warn "Float:\t" ,$VERSION->numify;
warn "V-str:\t" ,$VERSION->normal;

my $v2 = $VERSION;

warn "Are both Version equal?:", $v1 == $v2;

warn "v-str bigger?:",  $v1 > 'v1.2.2';
warn "v-str smaller?:", $v1 < 'v1.2.4';
warn "v-str not smaller?:", $v1 < 'v1.2.2';

#
# --------------------------------------------------
[download]

 -*- mode: compilation; default-directory: "d:/exp/" -*-
Compilation started at Fri Jul 10 19:13:58

C:/Perl_524/bin\perl.exe  d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl 
IN:        v1.2.3 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 29.
Str:    v1.2.3 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 69.
Float:    1.002003 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 70.
V-str:    v1.2.3 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 71.
IN:        1.002003 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 29.
Str:    1.002003 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 78.
Float:    1.002003 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 79.
V-str:    v1.2.3 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 80.
Are both Version equal?:1 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 84.
v-str bigger?:1 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 86.
v-str smaller?:1 at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 87.
v-str not smaller?: at d:/exp/Version_Easy.pl line 88.

Compilation finished at Fri Jul 10 19:13:58
[download]