in reply to New Feature: Thread Watcher

Interesting feature.

When I did my recent reply elsewhere, I was surprised to see the cb told me You said "[id://1158292] posted [id://11157997] as a comment somewhere under [id://11157983]" to [MonkNameHere] . Since I hadn't yet read your message, I was a bit confused as to how I sent that message, and started investigating my cb recently-sent, trying to figure out what happened. (Also, the cb message gave the raw links as I quoted, rather than link-rendering.)

Was it intentional that you also message the poster that someone watched them post?

Someone making a reply might get a little annoyed at seeing a dozen notifications that they msg'd everyone who happened to be watching a popular thread.

And moreso, [MonkNameHere] might get a little annoyed that their watching of the discussion becomes semi-public knowledge. (I know some monks value staying hidden, even when they do log in, and might be upset to find out that I happened to know they were watching a particular conversation.)

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: New Feature: Thread Watcher
by jdporter (Paladin) on Feb 29, 2024 at 21:33 UTC

    Thank you for the report. I've done some testing, and at this point I'm pretty sure that that message you saw in your cb was spurious, and factually inaccurate. I got it too, in my tests. But only the person who has registered for a notification will actually get it. I need to figure out why you got that message.

    Update: Fixed.