in reply to OT - What path will we tread?

You are correct, if we attempt to punish the wrong people, the cycle of violence will not end. We've seen that multiple times.

However, I believe that Friend Ansary (apologies, but I really don't know the naming conventions involved) is somewhat incorrect.

The argument "I do believe that suffering and poverty are the soil in which terrorism grows" rings false with me. I fully, completely, and vehemently disagree. Strongly even. Terrorism grows in the poisoned soils of intolerance, arrogance, and non-acceptance. Suffering and poverty beget a desire for action...which is easily manipulated into inappropriate zealotry and--sadly--acts against humanity couched in the trappings of religious idealism.

I'd love to argue--in RL--the various points quoted by the alleged originator. Not that I distrust you, but I distrust anything sent via email. (Sorry.)

Let's focus on first principles: Are you angry, hurt, offended, whatever? Then, please, CONTRIBUTE POSITIVELY. Look around you. There are many people needing true compassion, true help. GIVE IT.

Make a difference by putting yourself on the line and by taking a stand. Help others. Give 'til it hurts--and then give again. And, above all else, borrow a line from the Hippocratic Oath: "Above all else, do no harm."

--f

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: Re: OT - What path will we tread?
by scott (Chaplain) on Sep 18, 2001 at 20:00 UTC

    I certainly had qualms about posting a message from 'some guy who knows some guy who says ...' but, outside of the actual names of the senders and the little bit of biography at the front, and the obvious exageration (I doubt the Taleban execute women *for being women*, although they certainly execute people, including women, for things we never would), I don't see much questionable in the post. And, given the current situation, I think the main point, that the Afghanis are not the Taleban and killing innocents is no different than what Osama does, needs to be said.

    Scott