in reply to Re: RFC: Better Best Answers
in thread RFC: Better Best Answers

Hi,

Re Beech's suggestion (above) on tags/keywords: I'm inclined to agree with Tye's remark at Re: Keyword Nodelet / Tagging documentation (vote > privilege))

:)

I think what I'm really suggesting is buttons,

like a root node has a [mark as good faq question]

and a reply has a [mark as good answer]

I don't think I care too much if that results in some kind of tag/keyword in keyword nodelet, or a "good" flag"

or simply a  +=2 upvote

What I do care, is that its a button, that its always available for me to click it, even if I'm out of votes for the day

vote when out of votes for "good questions" and "best answers" with buttons

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^3: RFC: Better Best Answers (vote when out of votes)
by jdporter (Paladin) on Sep 15, 2016 at 12:56 UTC
    I think what I'm really suggesting is buttons,

    like a root node has a [mark as good faq question]

    and a reply has a [mark as good answer]

    ...

    What I do care, is that its a button, that its always available for me to click it, even if I'm out of votes for the day

    Ah! You have described what I'm envisioning the QandAEditors will be able to do!

    It would be a two stage process: (1) rank-and-file monks increase the rep of good nodes with extra votes; (2) QandAEditors attach special flags to "faqish" questions and "best" answers. I'm afraid you might have gotten the two mixed up a little.

    Thank you!

    I reckon we are the only monastery ever to have a dungeon stuffed with 16,000 zombies.
[reply]
[d/l]
[select]

In Section Perl Monks Discussion