in reply to Re: [RFC] Building Regex Alternations Dynamically
in thread Building Regex Alternations Dynamically

So a standard reverse sort expression serves in all cases.

As I /msg'ed you at the time you posted this, I had a doubt about this - and now I've finally found the time to confirm that I wasn't being entirely paranoid ;-) Under locale, it's possible for longer strings to be sorted before shorter ones. Here are the instructions to reproduce (on a Debian-based system):

$ mkdir -v /tmp/localetest; cd /tmp/localetest # copy "en_US" and the files it refers to via its "copy" statements $ cp -v /usr/share/i18n/locales/{en_US,en_GB,i18n,iso14651_t1,iso14651 +_t1_common} . $ mv -v en_US en_TESTING

Now edit the file en_TESTING and insert the following into the LC_COLLATE section after the copy "iso14651_t1" statement:

collating-element <bc> from "<U0062><U0063>" script <TESTING> order_start <TESTING>;forward;forward;forward;forward,position <bc> "<a><c>";"<BAS><BAS>";"<MIN><MIN>";IGNORE order_end

Now compile and test the locale:

$ localedef -i en_TESTING -f UTF-8 -c ./en_TESTING.UTF-8 $ LOCPATH=/tmp/localetest LC_ALL=en_TESTING.UTF-8 perl -Mlocale -le 'p +rint for sort qw/ab a b bc/' a ab bc b $ LOCPATH=/tmp/localetest LC_ALL=en_TESTING.UTF-8 perl -wMstrict -lMlo +cale print "1 $_" for "abcabbc"=~/${\join "|", reverse sort qw(b bc) }/g; print "2 $_" for "abcabbc"=~/${\join "|", sort {length$b<=>length$a} q +w(b bc) }/g; __END__ 1 b 1 b 1 b 2 bc 2 b 2 bc

Now of course the real locale definitions are long and I don't plan on reading all of them, and so it's entirely possible that currently no locales exist that define this kind of sorting order. But I'll just be a bit paranoid and stick with sorting by length explicitly :-)

Update: I did incorporate your suggestion about highlighting the fact that strings are matched literally, thank you!

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^3: [RFC] Building Regex Alternations Dynamically
by AnomalousMonk (Archbishop) on May 15, 2017 at 21:32 UTC

    In all my CS/IS career, I've been able get away with taking no more than a couple of quick steps into locale-land and then turning and scurrying back to safety. I will have to do a lot more reading and experimenting to be able to respond meaningfully to what you've posted, but it looks... interesting.


    Give a man a fish:  <%-{-{-{-<