in reply to Re^2: readdir() on a sysopen() handle?
in thread readdir() on a sysopen() handle?

The problem is that an entry might change from a directory to a symbolic link between the stat() and the open().

Wouldn't a second stat() after the open tell? Well duh, the underlying file could just switch back from symlink to directory between the open() and the second stat, e.g. something that emulates a directory via a maliciously loaded file system module doing sinister things. Just curious - what problem are you trying to solve?

Correct me if I am wrong, but after getting a handle to something, even if the something is renamed, deleted, and symlinked back, it holds to the original structure being accessed:

my $path = '/tmp/open'; -d $path and die "remove $path first\n"; mkdir $path; for (qw(foo bar quux)) { open my $fh, '>',"$path/$_"; } mkdir "$path/baz"; for (qw(blorf blorfldyick)) { open my $fh,'>', "$path/baz/$_"; } opendir my $dh1, $path; while(readdir $dh1) { next if /^\.\.?$/; print "read(dh1): $path/$_\n"; if (-d "$path/$_") { opendir my $dh2, "$path/$_" or die; # emulate external change directory to symlink rename "$path/$_","$path/fie"; symlink "$path/fie", "$path/$_" or die; # end emulate if(-l "$path/$_") { print "bogus change to $path/$_:\n"; print " $path/$_ points to ",readlink "$path/$_","\n"; } while (my $e = readdir $dh2) { next if $e =~ /^\.\.?$/; print "read(dh2): $e\n"; } } } __END__ read(dh1): /tmp/open/foo read(dh1): /tmp/open/quux read(dh1): /tmp/open/baz bogus change to /tmp/open/baz: /tmp/open/baz points to /tmp/open/fie read(dh2): blorf read(dh2): blorfldyick read(dh1): /tmp/open/bar

Side note which might resolve this XY Problem (if so): -d on a symlink returns true up to v5.25.10, so -d resolves symlinks, which it shouldn't do. IMHO this is a bug.

Apropos race condition: I can't think of anything which would resolve that, other than a system call like openif() into which the expected type is passed as an argument.

perl -le'print map{pack c,($-++?1:13)+ord}split//,ESEL'

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^4: readdir() on a sysopen() handle?
by perlhuhn (Novice) on Aug 21, 2017 at 15:28 UTC
    -d following symlinks is not a bug because it calls stat() which follows symlinks as required by POSIX. You have to use lstat() (or -l) if you don't want that.