[Perl6] Small 6 discoveries V, Sigils

Some people like sigils. Some people don't. In Perl 6 you don't have to use them (as much).

my $x = 1; say $x;
my \y = 1; say y;

my @x = 1, 2; say @x;
my \y = @ = 1, 2; say y;

# also works with signatures
sub foo(\x) { say x }; foo(1);
[download]

However you can't use sigilless attributes

class ThisExplodes
{
  has \.y; #doesnt work
  has \y;  #neiter does this
}
[download]

You can use this for example to distinguish normal variables from ones in closures, or lexicals from function arguments or whatever. Or maybe you event want to get rid of all sigils where possible.

The choice is yours.

Addendum
Sigilless variables do not create containers and are always immutable after initialization. They are therefore not a simple replacement with different visuals.

Edit: Fixed typo as hinted by NetWallah

holli

You can lead your users to water, but alas, you cannot drown them.

Comment on [Perl6] Small 6 discoveries V, Sigils Select or Download Code

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: [Perl6] Small 6 discoveries V, Sigils by Laurent_R (Canon) on Oct 09, 2017 at 06:27 UTC
I certainly don't want to get rid of sigils. In the proprietary programming language that I am using the most frequently after Perl, all variable names start with with a # character. Then, I am also doing quite a bit of shell programming, where variables start with $ (when you use hem). So, when I am using other programming languages su as C, Python or Scala, I have trouble telling variables from other identifiers. Sigils are so useful for me to know at first sight what kind of a beast I'm dealing with! I have almost come to the feeling that sigil-less programming languages are somewhat crippled. ;-)	[reply]
Re^2: [Perl6] Small 6 discoveries V, Sigils by Anonymous Monk on Oct 23, 2017 at 21:32 UTC
I agree with Laurent. And I could do with more sigil, which is more controversial. As much I would like to get rid of the € as a French currency, I would like to have it as sigil for types that are Associative, Positional and Scalar. Many kinds of tree nodes could have that property. In Perl 6, a match acts like it has these properties but can't advertise it with .^roles (see below). $/ would be written as €/. Ironically, a non match is Nil and not Match. And one successful match value cannot be used as an invocant to .^roles : `'a' ~~ /a/; say $/.^roles OUTPUT: «(exit code 1) Unexpected named argument 'transitive' passed` [download]	[reply] [d/l]