I understand your point, but we are all guests here. And it's the duty of the hosts to keep the house clean, at least from the outside.

If others want to read "disputed" sub-trees, they can simply log in.

If you want your opinion to be legible to the world, buy web-space (or endure the side costs of so called social networks)

NB: We always had REAPED nodes (AFAIR) and it didn't hinder you collaborating here. This new approach is just a much weaker, but more flexible version of it. And nobody said it's perfect and can't be improved in the future ...