in reply to RE: RE: RE: Randomize List of items
in thread Randomize List of items
:-)
Okay, after 14 minutes (!), I saw similar results. The problem, as I see it, is not the distribution around the median, but the predictability of successive elements.
Any given number may have an equal chance of being at any
location in the result array. However, there seems to be
a very large probability (certainly greater than random)
that for a given element, the element which starts next to
this one will end up very close to wherever this element
ends up.
At least in the case of pre-sorted input (which we all used), close neighbors tend to not only stay near
each other, but to stay in the same order. Given that Perl
uses a quicksort-based implementation, this will likely be
true of all input data.
Obviously, neither of the two solutions (the original post and this one) is suitable for strong cryptography (no solution which only uses a pseudo-random number generator will be).
Russ
|
---|