in reply to Re: Book Reputations
in thread Book Reputations

IMHO, reserving dedicated votes for books would reduce the sense of responsibility of the voting monk.
The voting system in the Monastery is all about knowledge.
I vote positively a node if I feel that it is giving me (or the community) something in terms of knowledge. Conversely, I vote negatively when I see that a node is giving me useless - or wrong - information. Even when I vote ++ for a "cool" node, not something that explains me how to use map or grep, I give my vote because that node is contributing to the spirit of the community.
I would not mind using up some of my votes for books (I don't suppose I will be voting on books every day, after all!), if I feel that they are influencing (positively or negatively) my technical education.
_ _ _ _ (_|| | |(_|>< _|