Re: Re (tilly) 2: Getting MySQL Data into an Array.

Okay, I have to say that Tilly is right on one point. If I am going to criticize the question, I should have been more specific. (I even gave Tilly a ++ vote for that point.)

I will do that next time.

However, my point is still valid and Tilly does not seem to recognize that. (We had a long discussion about it this morning.) While I am sure the cdherold is normally a fine programmer, s/he sounds like s/he is being lazy here.

S/he is smart and resouceful enough to know about DBI and got those variable names from the documentation or a close proximity there of, but sounds here to by saying:

"I tried once, it failed. Help me!"

I am not trying to scare off some relative newbie. I am trying to challenge them to think things through before asking the questions. Try it a few different ways, do some research. It does him/her a disservice to write their code for them.

I don't believe my tone was as harsh as Tilly says. If so, it was not my intention to sound harsh. I truely wonder if he/she was attempting to use execute() in a new way. If so, I commend that, but the question was worded poorly if that is the case.

I admit it, I am Paco.

Comment on Re: Re (tilly) 2: Getting MySQL Data into an Array.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re (tilly) 4: Getting MySQL Data into an Array. by tilly (Archbishop) on Jan 07, 2002 at 04:25 UTC
Please stop trying to justify yourself. Your point is not valid. As the old saying goes, Don't make an ass* of u and me.* The questioner does indeed know of DBI and used the variable names that its documentation uses. That tells you little. That just means that said person somewhere has seen code that uses DBI, and that code used the same variable names that DBI does. You have no idea where that code came from. It could be from DBI, yes. It could be from an old database script that happened to be laying around. Perhaps it is from a book he picked up. There are a lot of web pages you can get DBI code samples like that from - not a few of which are at perlmonks in fact. (Which happens to be the only Perl resource we know this person knows about. And we only know that because this is where the question was asked.) And for most of those possible sources, the odds are very good that the variable names chosen would be the same as (or at least similar to) the ones in the DBI documentation. But if the questioner had actually had the DBI documentation to refer to, there would be a lot of likely looking select methods they would be likely to try. So you do not know that they have ever seen anything looking like documentation. (In fact I think it is unlikely that they had.) And given that most beginning Perl programmers that I have seen don't know where to find documentation, this is not a good assumption to make. As for how harsh you were, I summarized how I think I would have reacted to your post had I asked the question and didn't know enough about the Perl world (note that the questioner had not used Perl in a very long time - and said that up front) to know where to find the answers. Furthermore I advise you to reflect on your behaviour in chatter when multiple people objected to the tone implied in your post. I am paraphrasing from memory, but I think that statements like, If they can't stand the heat then they should get out of the fire and, Perhaps it will be incentive for him to solve his own problem next time indicates that - whatever your intention, you apparently didn't much care if it came off as belittling and rude. Now that may have been just frustration that people were not agreeing with you, but those aren't the attitudes we really want to encourage around here. (On a similar note we also try to avoid having many threads which are this heated. Which is why what I really want to see happen is for this discussion to be dropped, for you to think about it, and for the issue to simply never come up again...)	[reply]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.

Re (tilly) 4: Getting MySQL Data into an Array.
by tilly (Archbishop) on Jan 07, 2002 at 04:25 UTC

Your point is not valid. As the old saying goes, Don't make an ass of u and me. The questioner does indeed know of DBI and used the variable names that its documentation uses. That tells you little. That just means that said person somewhere has seen code that uses DBI, and that code used the same variable names that DBI does. You have no idea where that code came from. It could be from DBI, yes. It could be from an old database script that happened to be laying around. Perhaps it is from a book he picked up. There are a lot of web pages you can get DBI code samples like that from - not a few of which are at perlmonks in fact. (Which happens to be the only Perl resource we know this person knows about. And we only know that because this is where the question was asked.)

And for most of those possible sources, the odds are very good that the variable names chosen would be the same as (or at least similar to) the ones in the DBI documentation. But if the questioner had actually had the DBI documentation to refer to, there would be a lot of likely looking select methods they would be likely to try.

So you do not know that they have ever seen anything looking like documentation. (In fact I think it is unlikely that they had.) And given that most beginning Perl programmers that I have seen don't know where to find documentation, this is not a good assumption to make.

As for how harsh you were, I summarized how I think I would have reacted to your post had I asked the question and didn't know enough about the Perl world (note that the questioner had not used Perl in a very long time - and said that up front) to know where to find the answers.

Furthermore I advise you to reflect on your behaviour in chatter when multiple people objected to the tone implied in your post. I am paraphrasing from memory, but I think that statements like, If they can't stand the heat then they should get out of the fire and, Perhaps it will be incentive for him to solve his own problem next time indicates that - whatever your intention, you apparently didn't much care if it came off as belittling and rude. Now that may have been just frustration that people were not agreeing with you, but those aren't the attitudes we really want to encourage around here.

(On a similar note we also try to avoid having many threads which are this heated. Which is why what I really want to see happen is for this discussion to be dropped, for you to think about it, and for the issue to simply never come up again...)

[reply]