in reply to Add instruction to use a "good description title"?

While you definately have good points about titles, and descriptive titles are clearly a "Good Thing(tm)", i would like to point out that on every single messageboard type system, the group that really needs to listen to this (aka newbs..) never does. No matter how many 'Please post legible titles..' you still get lots. But hey, maybe thats just my pessimism..
  • Comment on Re: Add instruction to use a "good description title"?

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: Re: Add instruction to use a "good description title"?
by graff (Chancellor) on Apr 23, 2002 at 21:53 UTC
    This is definitely an area where help is needed, and you can't hope for the newbies to help themselves here. So how about a generic "keywords" attachment to each posting label (which will sometimes be helpful even when higher-ups are posting).

    For example, when a posting is submitted, the process that formats the posting title could take the time to scan the text and see what sorts of familiar terms are in there (CGI, DBI, ODBC, regex or "regular expression", etc) -- and even rank these by frequency -- pick about three of these and include them automatically as part of the title.

    The really clueless posters might miss all the important terms, but if they look at the "keyword" portion of other postings, and see that their own post has none, they might figure it out.

    The title could even contain a little flag to indicate whether the posting contains any <code>, if that seems important.

Re: Re: Add instruction to use a "good description title"?
by perlmoth (Hermit) on Apr 24, 2002 at 15:10 UTC
    I have a suggestion.

    You could write a function to measure the descriptiveness of the title, and if it falls below some threshold prevent the message getting posted. Then the user will be forced to post a more descriptive title.

    Obviously "descriptiveness" is a fairly subjective measure, but it should be possible to automate it to find the worst offenders. e.g.:

    if (word_count($title) <= 3) { print "You cannot post this until you put in a more descriptive titl +e." ... }
    The implemetation of a more sophisticated function "measure_descriptiveness()" could be left as an exercise for perl monks...