in reply to RE: RE: Categorized Q&A Cleanup Finally....
in thread Categorized Q&A Cleanup Finally....

I don't think having an answer take a while in Q&A is such a bad thing. Q&A is meant for common, general questions which will help many people down the line. As such, the answers should be fairly general and definitely well thought-out. These two things require more time than firing off a quickly hacked solution or workaround. Questions regarding how to do something very specific should be put in SOPW, since the whole site is set up to prioritize those questions. I still don't think the warning in Q&A that many valid questions are inappropriate for that section is big enough; perhaps mentioning that answers are likely to take longer and not relate as specifically to the problem will discourage people (especially AMs) from posting off-topic questions.
  • Comment on RE: RE: RE: Categorized Q&A Cleanup Finally....

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
RE: RE: RE: RE: Categorized Q&A Cleanup Finally....
by KM (Priest) on Jun 07, 2000 at 03:37 UTC
    I think answers taking a long time in not a Good Thing. Imaging this scenario:
    Q: Where can I learn about regular expressions?
    ... someone answers perlpre withing 2 minutes...
    ... 6 hours go by because no moderators are online ...
    A moderator comes online, sees 30 Q&A to weed through, spends an hour on it, doesn't get to this one. In the meantime, 10 other people answer.... moderators get bogged down having to approve EVERY answer before they get posted.. people get angry at moderators because no answers are being posted... etc...

    Cheers,
    KM

      SOPW exists for fast answers. Q&A exists for good answers.

      <KM> I see no reason why Q&A can't be both
      <neshura> do you always like to optimize for two variables?
      <KM> no but...
      <neshura> i ROCK and you know it :)

      (hypothetical chatter, just kidding KM)

      e-mail neshura

        Why not have quick and good answers??? :) Maybe I am confused by the Q&A and SoPW sections. Either way... I hypthetically know you rock.

        Cheers,
        KM