Aye not only can message ID be broken, you may find that they are not unique. the md5 aproch listed above will catch any unique message.

-Waswas

I found a little script I used many years ago to merge some mailboxes; it uses formail and computes md5 of every message to check for duplicates:

# shell script
for file in inboxes/* ;
do
  echo "removing digests";
  rm -f digests/*;
  echo "removing output/$file";
  rm "output/$file";
  echo "digesting $file";
  cat $file | formail -ds ./save $file;
  echo ;
done
[download]

# Perl script 'save'
#!/usr/bin/perl

use strict;
use Digest::MD5  qw(md5_hex);

use vars qw($data $digest $mbox);

$mbox = shift @ARGV;

while (<>) {
  $data .= $_;
}

$digest = md5_hex($data);

if (-e "digests/$digest") {
  print "!";
} else {
  open(F, ">>output/$mbox") or die "outbox: $!";
  print F $data;
  close(F);

  open(G, ">digests/$digest") or die "digests: $!";
  print G "\n";
  close(G);

  print ".";
}
[download]

formail was used because I didn't find a solution to split a mailbox using Perl. It will probably fail to detect a duplicate when the same message has different status (new, read, answered, etc).

HTH, Valerio

Makeshifts last the longest.