This is not a feature request but rather a general analyzis of the situtation that should be usefull in future discussions about changing the information categorisation in PM. First I would like to note that categorisation is only usefull when there is too much information to read. Otherwise you don't need to choose and can read just all the available information - that's quite obvious. Using categories you can pick only the information that would be usefull for you. So the goal is to have such a granulity of the categorisation that after choosing the category you can read everything that is inside.

There are two modes of reading the content of PM:

In the first case the most important is categorisation by quality/importance of the post. In the second case much more important is that the information is really something relevant. Actually those two cases are one in disguise - the first has a broad topic - Perl in generall, and since the topic is broad you have an abundance of available information in it - you have to filter it by quality, the second has a narrow topic so you can read anything inside that category and you don't need to subdivide it.

Actually "Browsing new posts" is a bit more complicated - it should be "Browsing posts", but that would lead to such a big category that would make us insane, so we add the category "new". This step is a bit arbitrary - it leaves a whole lot of high quality nodes outside.

What are the implications? I leave this as an open question.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: On categorisation
by waswas-fng (Curate) on Jun 20, 2003 at 21:16 UTC
    Browsing the new posts Searching for information relating to a particular subject In the first case the most important is categorisation by quality/importance of the post.

    Aye but who is to categorize these posts as "quality" or "important". Votes may tell us about the quality, but if you are doing sysadmin work with perl do you really want to waste time reading a very clever post about a math problem? My point is both measures are not very well defined for the individual, but more so for the community -- individuals need to be able to fine tune to their interests.

    -Waswas