in reply to Re: OT Rant Re: How to make a link, using cgi.pm, that opens a new window
in thread How to make a link, using cgi.pm, that opens a new window

I'm confused about that. you mean a pop-up window? A small window which explains the larger window, which it now partially obscures?

If the explanation is small enough, it should go on the page it's explaining. If it's too large, it should be on a page of its own, and let the user read it and go back.

Or of course you could redesign the first page so that it needed less explanation.

Every time someone argues for usability guidelines like "don't mess with the user's browser", someone else says "Except in my special case, that's right. But I can ignore that rule because..."



($_='kkvvttuubbooppuuiiffssqqffssmmiibbddllffss') =~y~b-v~a-z~s; print
  • Comment on Re: Re: OT Rant Re: How to make a link, using cgi.pm, that opens a new window
  • Download Code

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: Re: Re: OT Rant Re: How to make a link, using cgi.pm, that opens a new window
by menolly (Hermit) on Aug 20, 2003 at 22:53 UTC

    If you want to use JavaScript, sure, a small pop-up is one option.

    If you don't, target is what you have.

    Suppose you have explanatory/reference text a new user may want to see, but which would be mere visual clutter to an experienced user. Definitions of terminolgy, syntax reference, that sort of thing. Opening it in a new window allows the user to switch between the two easily.

    I've rarely, if ever, used target="_new" or target="_blank" on a general audience public site. I have used it on specialized internal tools, where it is necessary for the user to compare content the current page to that in the new window.