It is called debating, not arguing. And yes, I would never use it and can't see it's use. I see a better way to accomplish it while accomplishing more at the same time.

(rest of your post)...

As I said before, I want to know what type of problem this would solve. What good does it do for the site as a whole as opposed to being something some may use some of the time. You are just saying "I would use it, it wouldn't bother you, so deal", and that simply isn't good enough for me. I would rather vroom (or whomever) spend programming time for things to better the site for the masses, not for a few. I just don't see why seeing the rep for a post is so important. I think knowing which nodes have more votes can be useful to all, and seeing a posts rep by nullifying your vote on it is too individual.

Cheers,
KM