Re: Script or program?

The difference between a script and a program is one is a subset of another. A program is typically a piece of text that contains instructions. A script is a program that is interpreted in real time and then turns it into a lower level language. Of course, that leaves java, which isn't a script language, in a fuzzy definition.

As someone taught me, the opposite of black isn't white. The opposite of black is non-black. Think ven diagrams. :)

So the real question is, is, is consciousness a script or non-script. I think it's both. As a non-script program, we have things we don't need to put prior thought into.. things we may or may not even have a definite solution on. As a script program, we have problems and run through different scenarios, sketching out many solutions and scenarios in our heads and then running then thinking them out to see if they are really valid.

That's part of what makes us human, the ability to improvise and act upon it.

Play that funky music white boy..

Comment on Re: Script or program?

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: Re: Script or program? by duff (Parson) on Jan 10, 2004 at 18:56 UTC
The difference between a script and a program is one is a subset of another. A program is typically a piece of text that contains instructions. A script is a program that is interpreted in real time and then turns it into a lower level language. Of course, that leaves java, which isn't a script language, in a fuzzy definition. I agree that one is a subset of the other, but differ in your idea of what constitutes a script. To me, a program (in the computer programming sense) is a sequence of instructions for a computer to execute. These instructions can be in any form, assembly, C, Perl, byte code, whatever. A script is exactly the same thing but bent towards the human side of readability rather the computer side of readability. Scripts are most often higher-level languages because of this and I think the idea that "scripts are interpretted in real time" falls out of this merely as a matter of consequence. The higher-level the language the greater it's scriptiness If I created a C interpretter would the C programs I write for it suddenly be scripts? I don't think so. By your definition they would be. Scriptness is innate in the language, not the implementation. So, Java programs are also Java scripts in this sense. But that's just my opinion I think the whole idea of "script" vs "program" is sort of meaningless these days though. In the old days it meant interpretted vs. compiled, but that dichotomy has gotten fuzzier with time. duff	[reply]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.

Re: Re: Script or program?
by duff (Parson) on Jan 10, 2004 at 18:56 UTC

I agree that one is a subset of the other, but differ in your idea of what constitutes a script. To me, a program (in the computer programming sense) is a sequence of instructions for a computer to execute. These instructions can be in any form, assembly, C, Perl, byte code, whatever. A script is exactly the same thing but bent towards the human side of readability rather the computer side of readability. Scripts are most often higher-level languages because of this and I think the idea that "scripts are interpretted in real time" falls out of this merely as a matter of consequence. The higher-level the language the greater it's scriptiness

If I created a C interpretter would the C programs I write for it suddenly be scripts? I don't think so. By your definition they would be. Scriptness is innate in the language, not the implementation. So, Java programs are also Java scripts in this sense. But that's just my opinion

I think the whole idea of "script" vs "program" is sort of meaningless these days though. In the old days it meant interpretted vs. compiled, but that dichotomy has gotten fuzzier with time.

duff

[reply]