If you're using 5.8.*, then stick with what you have:

c:\test>\perl\bin\perl5.8.6.exe -s junk9.pl -N=1e2
        Rate ysth  buk  tye   OP
ysth  4371/s   -- -47% -49% -75%
buk   8269/s  89%   --  -3% -53%
tye   8542/s  95%   3%   -- -52%
OP   17779/s 307% 115% 108%   --

c:\test>\perl\bin\perl5.8.6.exe -s junk9.pl -N=1e5
       Rate ysth  buk  tye   OP
ysth 3.75/s   -- -36% -39% -64%
buk  5.88/s  57%   --  -4% -44%
tye  6.15/s  64%   5%   -- -41%
OP   10.5/s 179%  78%  70%   --
[download]

If you're using 5.10, as unintuative as it sounds, a split/join solution seems to be the fastest. Especially when the strings get up into the megabyte range:

c:\test>\Perl510\bin\perl5.10.0.exe -s junk9.pl -N=1e2
       Rate ysth  tye   OP  buk
ysth 2326/s   -- -50% -64% -72%
tye  4670/s 101%   -- -27% -45%
OP   6417/s 176%  37%   -- -24%
buk  8419/s 262%  80%  31%   --

c:\test>\Perl510\bin\perl5.10.0.exe -s junk9.pl -N=1e5
       Rate ysth   OP  tye  buk
ysth 1.83/s   -- -32% -46% -69%
OP   2.70/s  48%   -- -21% -55%
tye  3.42/s  87%  26%   -- -43%
buk  5.98/s 227% 121%  75%   --

c:\test>\Perl510\bin\perl5.10.0.exe -s junk9.pl -N=1e6
     s/iter    OP  ysth   tye   buk
OP     43.0    --  -54%  -60%  -96%
ysth   19.9  116%    --  -14%  -91%
tye    17.1  151%   16%    --  -90%
buk    1.72 2400% 1056%  896%    --
[download]

I'm quite prepared to have my intuition confirmed and benchmark proven wrong, but this is the second time this year I've benchmarked this and I can't see anything wrong with my benchmark.

The thing to note is that the performance of the split/join solution (buk) hardly varies between the two builds, but the cost of the substitutions seems to have really increased in 5.10. With or without capturing parens or /e.

The benchmark code:

#! perl -slw
use strict;
use Benchmark qw[ cmpthese ];

my %subst = ( '&' => 'amp', '>' => 'gt', '<' => 'lt' );

our $ysth = join('|', map quotemeta, sort { length($b) <=> length($a) 
+|| $b cmp $a } keys %subst);

our $N ||= 1e3;
our $data = join( '', map{ 'junk ' . (qw[ & < > ])[ rand 3 ]  } 1 .. $
+N );

cmpthese -3, {
    OP      => sub {
        $_ = $data;
        s{\&}{amp}g;
        s{\<}{lt}g;
        s{\>}{gt}g
    },
    tye     => sub {
        $_ = $data;
        s{([&<>])}{$subst{$1}}ge;
    },
    ysth    => sub {
        $_ = $data;
        s{($ysth)}{$subst{$1}}ge;
    },
    buk     => sub {
        $_ = $data . ' ';
        $_ = join 'amp', split '&';
        $_ = join 'lt', split '<';
        $_ = join 'gt', split '>';
        chop;
    },
};
[download]

Have at it!