in reply to Offsite Tutorial Reviews?

a well written and well thought out tutorial that could be applied to any language

I beg to disagree.

Thet tutorial that you claim as an example has several negative points that we in the Monastery usually consider bad practice and advise against:

The works in our Tutorials page have passed the scrutiny of the Monastery, which is quick in pointing out problems and suggesting corrections. Had your exemplar tutorial been proposed here, it would have been torn to pieces in a couple of minutes.

Not to discourage you, but please come up with some better examples. We Perl Monks are, paraphrasing Oscar Wilde, people of simple tastes, we are always satisfied with the best. {grin}

BTW, our Tutorials already include links to (carefully chosen) external works.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: Offsite Tutorial Reviews?
by injunjoel (Priest) on Jul 18, 2004 at 19:08 UTC
    Greetings again,
    You bring up a very good point in regards to the tutorial link I provided but I feel you missed my intended concept. My desire is|was to guide readers through the concepts presented in these offsite tutorials, and perhaps make suggestions regarding the
    "several negative points that we in the Monastery usually consider bad practice and advise against"

    In fact the list you posted is exactly the sort of review of an offsite tutorial that I would hope for is the proposed section. Allow Monasterians the chance to refine or even rework the concepts presented and give our usual deliberate, contemplative and catholic suggestions for others to learn from. Simply because part of a tutorial is inefficient does not make all its suggestions invalid (?: throwing the baby out with the bath water if you will). I think there are a great many things to learn from anyone willing to teach, even though they may not be the best at it. In my opinion learning is more about the student's ability to learn than about the teachers ability to teach. I know people who learn life lessons from stubbing their toe and others who couldn't learn compassion from Christ... but I will leave that for another discussion.

    -injunjoel
    "I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who endowed us with sense, reason and intellect has intended us to forego their use." -Galileo