in reply to It just seems like so much work...

Not all decisions in a business are based on technical merit. There is also cost (developer time), ease of maintainability, and the number of developers on-staff that can maintain it. There are also other business/management issues that you may be unaware of.

Though don't get me wrong, a lot of decisions are made in companies based on little or inaccurate information, or just because the Big Boss thinks it's the Next Big Thing, but just be aware that Perl isn't always the best solution for the task, and while it seems that in this case it can probably do the job very nicely, there may be other (probably business) reasons they chose to go with what they did.

If you're involved in the early stages of a project, and you think Perl is the best choice for it, by all means express your opinion and back it up. Perhaps they just haven't heard of Perl being used in these types of things. You'd get bonus points for having a working prototype in an hour. Rapid development = major $$$ savings.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
(jcwren) RE: (2) It just seems like so much work...
by jcwren (Prior) on Nov 09, 2000 at 21:13 UTC
    If you're involved in the early stages of a project, and you think Perl is the best choice for it, by all means express your opinion and back it up. Perhaps they just haven't heard of Perl being used in these types of things. You'd get bonus points for having a working prototype in an hour. Rapid development = major $$$ savings.
    I agree with Fastolfe on this, but I've got to add that you have to make your argument stand on both technical and financial merits. If you're the only Perl programmer in a shop of 35 Javaheads, and even though you could produce it in half of the time of the Javaheads, the cost of training them and the support costs could far outweigh the cost of doing it with existing tools and skill sets.

    Although Perl is a great language, don't let personal bias (or language religion) drive the decision. In fact, if people perceive you as someone who favors a particular language but recognizes the technical merit of others, and knows when how and when to concede the argument gracefully, you'll get far more respect than if you just wander the halls bashing all other languages (and possibly decisions that you don't understand the full constaint set of).

    If you have a few moments, I think the last paragraph of (jcwren) RE: RE: why i may have to leave perl... expresses well how I feel about language bigotry.

    --Chris

    e-mail jcwren