'sendmail' is not recognized as an internal or external command, operable program or batch file. What am I doing wrong?

sendmail is the default sending method for MIME::Lite, so unless you specify otherwise, that's what it will try...

From the docs:

    MIME::Lite->send()
        When used as a classmethod, this can be used to specify a diff
+erent default mechanism for sending message. The initial default is:
            MIME::Lite->send("sendmail", "/usr/lib/sendmail -t -oi -oe
+m");
        However, you should consider the similar but smarter and taint
+-safe variant:
            MIME::Lite->send("sendmail");

        Or, for non-Unix users:
            MIME::Lite->send("smtp");
[download]

Since you're a non-unix user you should want something more like:

if ($I_DONT_HAVE_SENDMAIL) {
           MIME::Lite->send('smtp', "smtp.myisp.net", Timeout=>60);
        }
[download]