Ahh I didn't look in SQL:: ... frankly I didn't even know there was a SQL::. In that case I would have to re research. Our disagreement then is still over weather it is a duplicate or not and weather this adds to DWIM or not. For me the abundance of Template modules lets me pick and choose. I use two different CPAN templating modules and one of my own concoction depending on what I need to do. Thats why I mentioned DWIM. " TMTOWTDI is not a universally good thing." I would disagree because giving more than one option means that you are more likly to fit the one that fits your need. I would say that most of the options on CPAN need better explanations of how they differ though.

"but when someone asks for comments." Certainly understood, I just wanted to OP to see an opposing view. Wether he uploads it or not I wanted to make it clear some of use say yay while others say nay and hopefully provide him with some arguments both ways. I didn't mean to imply in anyway that you shouldn't have posted or even that you shouldn't have said what you did. I simply wanted to say I didn't agree and why.