heh... I'm sure you already realised that my "dig" was very much tongue-in-cheek...
but since you asked...here goes:

• it's erm... all orange ! (yes, yes.. I know it has to be that way otherwise you couldn't call it a pumpkin theme. hmmm, but then... I've seen a lot of green pumpkins :p)
• It's very LOUD (and I don't like loud, unless it's floyd)
• I don't like underlined links - they give me the irrits
• um.. that's it :)

Of course, all of the above is just (my) personal preference :)
And having said all this, I should also mention that I really like your Soothing Green Theme, and I've started using it :)
I should also say that I did ++ your Pumpkin Post. Which I guess is a bit ironic - but hey, they're my votes and I can do what I like with them :p

Cheers,
Darren :)