Evan,
You've obviously spent quite a bit of time on this and it is apparently something you feel quite strongly about.
But dude - try to take a step back and put this into perspective. I mean - in the overall scheme of things - how important is this?
...really?
I would hope that you must have much more important things going on in your life to devote your attention to - rather than getting worked up about how votes are cast at Perlmonks.
For what it's worth, my view on your topic is as follows: I don't have one.
Perlmonks is a great place - I love it. Soon after I started coming here I discovered that they would give me some votes to use each day. So more often than not I use them. If I see something I
particularly like, I give it a ++, and if I see something I
really don't like I give it a --.
It's as simple as that :)
And as our
friend has
put it so simply and eloquently,
why don't you just forget about XP/voting, and start posting about Perl?
Cheers,
--Darren