in reply to (OT) Redundant Backup

40GB is less than 10 DVDs worth of data. (less than 5 for dual-layer). With a little bit of up-front hardware cost, you can back up your collection, and take it off-site.

What you're discussing isn't quite as important with modern hard drives -- they're much better about checking for bad sectors, and the mean time between failures is much longer than the days of ~40MB disks. If you really wanted redundancy, you'd also want to deal with the failure of the disk controller, not just individual sectors, which would require moving to a RAID solution (or at the very least, mirroring your changes to another disk)

So, to answer your questions:

(yes, I know you can't rebuild the data from a CRC, but it would give enough to sense if something's gone wrong)

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: (OT) Redundant Backup
by fundflow (Chaplain) on Mar 27, 2006 at 13:50 UTC
    Thanks for the suggestions.

    I do have backups on optical media. Note that DVDs are assumed to be much less reliable than disks, and are much less convinent for use anyway.

    In the past 10 years this happened several times and so it hints that the drives are not that great. Making multiple copies is good, but would require a manual merging phase in case things go wrong. This is where a straightforward Perl script can come in handy.

    BTW, if you back up to optical media, have a look at DVDisaster. They give a good background and a nice program which I have been using for my backups.