Re: Using exec() for executing shell scripts in CGI

I would be asking myself a few things.. For example; is there any chance that someone will run your bash/whatever script from the command line? What if you fed your executable script some bogus info, will it blow up, ruin something? I don't know that you have to make an executable any less secure then a regular cgi script. It *is* easier to debug though then stinkin' cgi.. ack.. ugh. *cough*.. excuse me.

I'm not sure how far along you are in this venture- but i'll risk sounding obvious just in case and mention that: you have to remember that the script will not be run by *you*- it will be run by apache, or whatever user the web server is running as. Unless of course, you are running su exec- it lets scripts run with *your* permissions- super useful- but.. it means your scripts have the power to destroy any data that *you* can.

Also, if you need your script to do some freaky business like add or take out real users fromthe machine, i would look into sudo, which let's regular users (maybe a safer *you* or apache) do things to the machine that only root regularly can.

Personally, I have faced this kind of thing with making modules that have interface independent code/methods/subs- so.. it's really convenient for testing. And then your interface - be it cgi or cli- is almost (almost!) an afterthought.

Your module code would check all the parameters to make sure they are not crud- and then after something happens, it can check that it really did happen- etc. If your cli or your cgi calls the stuff- the meat is the same.

It's amazing how much the web can complicate a trivial task. sigh. Hope any of that helps.

Comment on Re: Using exec() for executing shell scripts in CGI

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: Using exec() for executing shell scripts in CGI by stumbler (Acolyte) on Dec 14, 2006 at 11:32 UTC
Thanks for the responses As mentioned in original post, I preset the executables I need to run using the following approach:- I have a hash which has the list of commands that can only be used. Something like.. `my %commands = ( opt1 => exe1, opt2 => exe2, opt3 => exe3, );` [download] In the CGI script, I have a variable , $runmode, which can take a value of 'opt1' or 'opt2' or 'opt3'. I retrieve the executable by $commands{ 'opt1' } and pass it on to the shell script. I don't do any admin activities such as adding new user, deleting or modifying existing user accounts, etc.. using CGI scripts.	[reply] [d/l]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.

Re^2: Using exec() for executing shell scripts in CGI
by stumbler (Acolyte) on Dec 14, 2006 at 11:32 UTC

Thanks for the responses

As mentioned in original post, I preset the executables I need to run using the following approach:-

I have a hash which has the list of commands that can only be used. Something like..

my %commands = (
        opt1  => exe1,
        opt2 => exe2,
        opt3 => exe3,
    );
[download]

In the CGI script, I have a variable , $runmode, which can take a value of 'opt1' or 'opt2' or 'opt3'. I retrieve the executable by $commands{ 'opt1' } and pass it on to the shell script.

I don't do any admin activities such as adding new user, deleting or modifying existing user accounts, etc.. using CGI scripts.

[reply]
[d/l]