Re^2: recommendations on scientific computing with Perl

Hi educated_foo,

Thanks for the comment. I agree with you in that Perl is an excellent glue language. However, I also think that it is capable of much more than that but I will leave that for another post :-) By the way, I am also interested in articles and books related to the use of Perl as a glue language for scientific computation. For example, articles in which CPAN modules for machine learning ( some of which are Perl bindings to C/C++ libraries ) are used. If you know of such articles, please, let me know.

Cheers,

lin0

Comment on Re^2: recommendations on scientific computing with Perl

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^3: recommendations on scientific computing with Perl by educated_foo (Vicar) on Feb 13, 2007 at 22:05 UTC
I work in machine learning and use Perl for most of my scripting, but have never bothered to use CPAN's machine learning modules. First, you often need to do some additional linear algebra on your data (e.g. centering, finding eigenvalues, SVD, etc.), and these modules don't share a common matrix representation. The lack of a common format for compact storage and a rich library of numerical algorithms makes it hard to do things quickly in pure Perl. Second, many CPAN modules I've looked at seem to have been written either for their authors' edification or without caring about large datasets (e.g. Algorithm::SVMLight requires you to add your datapoints one at a time in bulky hash-refs), while most of the problems I care about involve huge amounts of data. I think the PDL statistics paper someone else mentioned is the best "perl for statistics" resource I've seen. Depending on your problems and level of familiarity with the field, there may be some articles on Perl.com of interest. As much as I loathe Java, I would actually recommend Weka as an implementation of lots of machine learning algorithms that work well together. But unless PDL does what you want, I'd suggest something other than Perl (including CPAN modules) for your core algorithms.	[reply]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.

Re^3: recommendations on scientific computing with Perl
by educated_foo (Vicar) on Feb 13, 2007 at 22:05 UTC

Algorithm::SVMLight

I think the PDL statistics paper someone else mentioned is the best "perl for statistics" resource I've seen. Depending on your problems and level of familiarity with the field, there may be some articles on Perl.com of interest. As much as I loathe Java, I would actually recommend Weka as an implementation of lots of machine learning algorithms that work well together. But unless PDL does what you want, I'd suggest something other than Perl (including CPAN modules) for your core algorithms.

[reply]