Re: Re: RedWolf MonkChatter

Does XML::PYX and XML::Twig need XML::Parser(and thus expat)? I'm trying to get away from having folks need to compile that (which kinda breaks compiling though CPAN::shell).

But then, XML::PYX seems to use a similar engine that I'm using now.

--
$Stalag99{"URL"}="http://stalag99.keenspace.com";

Comment on Re: Re: RedWolf MonkChatter

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re: Re: Re: RedWolf MonkChatter by mirod (Canon) on Mar 01, 2001 at 07:47 UTC
All of the XML processing modules on CPAN are based on expat, including XML::Parser, XML::PYX, XML::Simple, XML::Twig and many more. I fail to see why it is such a problem. Yes it means you cannot install directly using CPAN. But it installs very easily under Unix and once again XML::Parser comes with Activestate's Windows port. I know CPAN is extremelly convenient but it is not the only valid method to install modules. If you want to do any serious XML processing you really need a proper parser. Using regexps is false laziness. It is akin to not using `strict`: good for a quick hack but a no-no for anything serious. Incidentally there are good reasons why expat is not bundled with XML::Parser anymore. It is used by other applications, Apache for example and bundling it lead to incompatibilities between the different versions and problems building them.	[reply]

Replies are listed 'Best First'.

Re: Re: Re: RedWolf MonkChatter
by mirod (Canon) on Mar 01, 2001 at 07:47 UTC

All of the XML processing modules on CPAN are based on expat, including XML::Parser, XML::PYX, XML::Simple, XML::Twig and many more.

I fail to see why it is such a problem. Yes it means you cannot install directly using CPAN. But it installs very easily under Unix and once again XML::Parser comes with Activestate's Windows port. I know CPAN is extremelly convenient but it is not the only valid method to install modules.

If you want to do any serious XML processing you really need a proper parser. Using regexps is false laziness. It is akin to not using strict: good for a quick hack but a no-no for anything serious.

Incidentally there are good reasons why expat is not bundled with XML::Parser anymore. It is used by other applications, Apache for example and bundling it lead to incompatibilities between the different versions and problems building them.

[reply]