It's a good thread, you say so yourself. The fact that the question was poor doesn't really matter, what came out of it was interesting, and therefore is a showcase of how the site works.

I see your point. I'm half hearted though. I'd like to hear other people's position on the subject... short of doing what halley suggested, which is always a temptation, given that the thread has been stimulating for myself. Of course, actually following the advice is much a matter of balance between one's lazyness and hubris. But plain impatience would suggest to frontpage without thinking too much... :-)