in reply to Giving Non-Node ++?

Maybe just allow monks to vote on other monks' home nodes? Of course, you would only be able to vote once on a given monk, and I think that's sensible.

I expect that those monks who try to make their home nodes useful and helpful would also appreciate that sort of feedback. But there may be some good reason(s) (which I just can't think of myself) for not supporting votes on home nodes.

A problem with providing any sort of "spontaneous vote" on a monk's XP, with the ability to vote repeatedly on the same monk, is the (silly but inevitable) potential for abuse.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^2: Giving Non-Node ++?
by johnlawrence (Monk) on Oct 09, 2007 at 14:13 UTC
    I certainly like the idea of being able to upvote or recommend home nodes, though I'd rather not see a '--' for them (not that you suggested that) as your home node should be whatever you want to put there (within reason) and largely beyond criticism.

    '++' on the other hand, or something similar would be great particularly as it could be used to give a list of best or 'most useful' home nodes.

      If you vote ++ on a home node once, you would not be allowed to vote ++ on the same home node again.

      --
      [ e d @ h a l l e y . c c ]