in reply to Re: encryption golf (one time pad)
in thread encryption golf (one time pad)

Very nice! Using the command-line parameters was a big win.

I was going for the shortest solution in a source file without counting the shebang line, but I certainly didn't specify that as a rule. I think it's good I didn't, because this is a nice solution.

Mine's more aesthetically pleasing to my eyes, but that's entirely subjective and I'm probably biased anyway. I also think mine's easier to commit to memory, but that's subjective too. You might find completely different things easier to memorize. Neither has anything to do with golf, but I thought they were nice touches considering the tight controls on free speech and on encryption software in some places. I know if I'm putting it on a shirt or into my skin, nice looking solutions get at least part of the consideration.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^3: encryption golf (one time pad)
by ikegami (Patriarch) on Mar 17, 2008 at 09:31 UTC

    I was going for the shortest solution in a source file without counting the shebang line

    If so, then mine is 6 to your 18. 

    #!/usr/bin/perl -0777p
$_^=<>

    [download]

    I think your method of counting isn't appropriate, though.

    Mine's more aesthetically pleasing to my eyes, but that's entirely subjective and I'm probably biased anyway

    No, I agree. I did say mine was crazy.

[reply]
[d/l]
      If you construct the shebang line like that, though, perhaps the "-0777p" should be counted? You'd still have a shorter solution, either way.

      What's really funny is I wrote mine in response to a 51-character one on a site all about trivially short encryption implementations, and now you go and trim 1/3 or 2/3 off of it again depending on how you count that.

      Update: s/0377/0777/ to match ikegami's update (Thanks, Corion).

[reply]
      If so, then mine is 6 to your 18.

      According to the general Perl golf rules (which can be seen, for example, here, near the bottom), "If you use options on the #! line, the options themselves are counted, including the leading space and -." (emphasis in the original). So  -0777pe"$_^=<>" would be 16.

      --
      David Serrano

[reply]
[d/l]
        On the command line, it's 16. In ikegami's file-based version, I count 13 including the leading space for the options. That's quite an improvement over 18.
[reply]

In Section Obfuscated Code