in reply to Re^3: Perl to convert US to UK punctuation/spelling?
in thread Perl to convert US to UK punctuation/spelling?

people who aren't as exposed to the internet and the mixing of language (pensioners and young children)

I think you would be hard pressed to find someone young or old these days who had not been exposed to Americanisms by way of the Internet or any other way.

Perhaps freewheel will let us know exactly why the translation needs to be so "English".

  • Comment on Re^4: Perl to convert US to UK punctuation/spelling?

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^5: Perl to convert US to UK punctuation/spelling?
by jhourcle (Prior) on Jun 16, 2008 at 15:38 UTC

    Maybe. But I still remember in the 80s, when I was living in Europe, and we went on a trip to London ... and I bought a transformer. I got it back to the hotel and I read the instructions on how to transform it, and wondered what the hell 'lift the bonnet' and 'open the boot' meant'.

    These days, I still have to beware of recipes on the internet -- if I see the word 'coriander', I have to wonder ... if it's British, it'd be what Americans call cilantro. If it's American, it's what the Brits call coriander seed. Of course, you also have to know the age of the recipe, as what we call 'milk' today used to be called 'sweet milk' while 'milk' referred to butter milk. (and 'buttermilk' today is runny yogurt, not what was left over from the butter churning)

    The point is -- depending on exactly what you're presenting and what's being presented, it has the potential to be misinterpreted, and then you run into both the recipient and the originator blaming each other. Just because you've seen some Americanisms doesn't mean that you've seen every one, and when you're dealing with dialects of the 'same' language, you run into cases where the recipient may think they understood and be wrong -- you've probably seen it if you have a non-technical manager and you try to explain something in technical jargon where a word has a different meaning in the technical context. (eg, make sure you don't use the word 'hack' when you don't mean 'crack')

      The point is -- depending on exactly what you're presenting and what's being presented, it has the potential to be misinterpreted, and then you run into both the recipient and the originator blaming each other.

      You're very likely right.

      The point I'm trying to make is that "English" no longer exists in a true form, if ever it did and that it would be impossible to translate US to UK english and cover all nuances on the way, so I felt it would be a pointless and expensive exercise to try and do so, unless of course there was a very specific reason for doing so.