in reply to Re^6: Perl vs C
in thread Perl vs C

Here is a simple thing that removes things from a Perl list that do not match a criteria.
#!usr/bin/perl -w use warnings; my @list = ("a1", "b23", "c45", "d1", "b43", "b65"); print join (" ",@list),"\n"; #prints: a1 b23 c45 d1 b43 b65 @list = grep{!/^b/}@list; #remove things that start with b print join (" ",@list),"\n"; #prints: a1 c45 d1

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^8: Perl vs C
by JavaFan (Canon) on Mar 16, 2009 at 14:23 UTC
    Now you're modifying an array, swapping one value (a list) for another (another list). Calling the array @list doesn't change the fact it's an array. The code below doesn't modify '3' either - it just replaces the value of a variable.
    my $var = 3; $var++; say $var; # Prints 4.
      I don't understand what you mean. Sure it is possible to modify a list! Just like in C, I can pass a reference to a list to be modified and it will be modified! In the code below, I am modifying the actual list since the sub uses the reference to that list.
      #!usr/bin/perl -w use warnings; sub modify_list { my $listRef = shift; @$listRef = grep{!/^b/}@$listRef; #note there is no "return" value here #the list has been modified!!!! } my @list = ("a1", "b23", "c45", "d1", "b43", "b65"); print join (" ",@list),"\n"; #prints: a1 b23 c45 d1 b43 b65 modify_list(\@list); print join (" ",@list),"\n"; #prints a1 c45 d1

        You've only modified array @list again. No lists were modified.

        You're also wrong about there being no return value. It's just being ignored.

        Just like in C, I can pass a reference to a list to be modified and it will be modified!

        Please demonstrate, with working and tested Perl, how to take a reference to a list without using an array. At that point, I will believe that Perl supports mutable first-class lists as data structures (instead of multiple items on the Perl stack or a series of comma-separated expressions in source code).