in reply to Re^4: Reinvent the wheel!
in thread Reinvent the wheel!

It kind of is my dollar being spent. Every time a perl hacker rewrites File::Find instead of writing something new that I might want and putting it on CPAN, I lose something.

Don't get me wrong -- I have useless projects too. But there is a cost to these things. We only have so much time to spend on free software.

Replies are listed 'Best First'.
Re^6: Reinvent the wheel!
by Porculus (Hermit) on Mar 23, 2009 at 09:12 UTC

    Your argument, if taken too far, would ultimately lead to the claim that the time spent by an absolute beginner going through the exercises in an introductory textbook could have been better spent writing production code!

    Really you only "lose something" if two assumptions hold:

    1. The perl hacker in question already knows enough to write a CPAN module you'd want to use; and
    2. The perl hacker in question does not learn anything from the exercise that s/he might use in future to create even better modules.

    Unless you can prove that both of these are the case -- and the second, I think, is close to unprovable -- then you have no reason to assume that you have lost anything.

[reply]
      Your argument, if taken too far....

      Then don't take it too far.

      I have personally seen two very experienced CPAN authors (names almost everyone on this site recognizes, as they've written and maintained code used and recommended countless times) pursue a pointless rewrite of code intended for delivery to a customer the night before delivery.

      Did that cost my business something? You bet.

      Opportunity costs of reinvention are very real. They don't always happen, but software project management is the art of managing risk.

[reply]
Re^6: Reinvent the wheel!
by tilly (Archbishop) on Mar 23, 2009 at 23:41 UTC
    I submit that every time someone who would like to be a Perl hacker rewrites File::Find to teach themselves new skills, the net benefit to you is positive, not negative. Why? Because you've lost nothing (the person lacked the skills to write something you'd have found useful), but have the potential of gaining down the road when that motivated person exercises their new-found skills.
[reply]
Re^6: Reinvent the wheel!
by zentara (Cardinal) on Mar 22, 2009 at 13:38 UTC
    The problem with putting all these little code favorites on CPAN, is module overload. There are so many single purpose modules out there now, that it can be hard to look thru them all, to find what you need. Also, are you trying to put end-use programmers out of work? If we have all code written in little modules, selectable from menus for insertion into programs,....you end up with Java. :-) Part of the fun of programming is figuring out algorithms and implementing them.

    And then there are other reasons to do it on your own.....for instance does File::Find use glob or readdir ? I'm too lazy to dig in and find out, BUT I rely on the constant glowing revues of modules such as File::Find, to lead me to trust it implicitly.

    I'm not really a human, but I play one on earth My Petition to the Great Cosmic Conciousness
[reply]

In Section Meditations