The problem with such a scale is that 99.99% of the people who play baseball don't even make it to the minor league - it only measures the top. I'd call anyone playing ball in the minor league an expert baseball player.
Comment on Re: bush league, major league, all star, hall of famer. legend
To the extent that the question has any utility at all (see gwadej's reply) that is not a problem. papidave's replyhits pretty close to why: when you are selecting a candidate for a position a base level of competency is assumed. You've got to have someone actually capable of doing the job. If the question provides any useful information, that information is related to finding the most appropriate candidate, not for making the cut between immediate rejection and further consideration.