in reply to Re^2: Match with line without a word
in thread Match with line without a word

use strict; use warnings; use Benchmark; my @strings = qw(exception:tex exception:mex asdf); Benchmark::cmpthese( -5, { 'one' => sub { my @filtered = grep { /exception:(?!tex)/} @strings +; }, 'two' => sub { my @filtered = grep { /exception/ && !/tex/ } @stri +ngs; }, }); __END__ Rate one two one 175458/s -- -15% two 207611/s 18% --

update: The filter expressions are different. The second one does not care whether tex is before of after exception and doesn't require a ':' after 'exception'. I have stumbled on a patch of my ignorance trying to make the second match the same strings as the first. The best I have so far is:

use strict; use warnings; use Benchmark; my @strings = qw(exception:tex exception:mex asdf tex:exception:mex); Benchmark::cmpthese( -5, { 'one' => sub { my @filtered = grep { /exception:(?!tex)/} @strings +; }, 'two' => sub { my @filtered = grep { /exception/ && !/tex/ } @stri +ngs; }, 'three' => sub { my @filtered = grep { pos = 0; /exception:/g && ! +/\Gtex/ } @strings; }, }); __END__ Rate three one two three 99554/s -- -18% -38% one 121692/s 22% -- -24% two 161067/s 62% 32% --

update: see also strange behavior of grep with global match [resolved]. Adding "pos = 0" is necessary to clear pos between iterations but it would not be necessary if there were only a single iteration. This makes it difficult to compare the efficiency of "/exception/g && !/\Gtex/".